Abstract. We describe an easily estimated complementary measure, the difference in restricted mean survival time (RMST), that requires fewer assumptions than the HR and is more readily interpretable. In other words, during the 10 years of follow-up, patients treated by D-penicillamine lost 2.85 years in average sense. Prior to Tian et al. The package was made and tested on R version 3.3.2. We conduct extensive simulations to evaluate the performance and operating characteristics of the RMST-based inference and against the hazard ratio-based inference, under various scenarios and design parameter setups. [6] Klein, J. P., Gerster, M., Andersen, P. K., Tarima, S. & Perme, M. P. (2008). Regression analysis of censored data using pseudo-observations. provide an argument that the restricted mean survival time should be the summary statistic used when the proportional hazards assumption is in doubt. Survival Analysis. Below is a sample code to perform the adjusted analyses. The package was made and tested on R … [4], Andersen et al. Three kinds of between-group contrast metrics (i.e., the difference in RMST, the ratio of RMST and the ratio of the restricted mean time lost (RMTL)) are computed. Hazard ratios (HRs) are frequently misinterpreted. Restricted Mean Survival Time – The Basic Idea. In base R, use difftime to calculate the number of days between our two dates and convert it to a numeric value using as.numeric. The variable time records survival time; status indicates whether the patient’s death was observed (status = 1) or that survival time was censored (status = 0).Note that a “+” after the time in the print out of km indicates censoring. While no statistical significance was observed (p=0.738), the 0.95 confidence interval (-0.665 to 0.939) was relatively tight around 0, suggesting that the difference in RMST would be at most +/- one year. Restricted mean survival time (RMST) is a clinically interpretable and meaningful survival metric that has gained popularity in recent years. One reason would be that adjusting for important prognostic factors may increase power to detect a between-group difference. There is a considerable body of methodological research about the restricted mean survival time as alternatives to the hazard ratio approach. outcome, the restricted mean survival time (RMST), that will be estimated in both arms of the trials included in MAC-NPC network meta-analysis. p(#) specifies the percentile of survival time to be computed. If the last observation(s) is not a death, then the survival curve estimate does not go to zero and the mean survival time cannot be estimated. a numeric value to rescale the survival time, e.g., if the input data to survfit were in days, scale=365 would scale the printout to years. Unlike median survival time, it is estimable even under heavy censoring. rmst2 Comparing restricted mean survival time Description Performs two-sample comparisons using the restricted mean survival time (RMST) as a summary measure of the survival time distribution. 710 Restricted mean survival time. See Royston and Parmar (2013) for a description of the use of the measure in RCTs. Version: 0.1.1: Depends: R (≥ 3.4.0) Imports: survival, survRM2: Miller, Rupert G., Jr. (1981). type The type of the between-group contrast measure: "difference"(default), "ratio" or "lossratio". For the difference metric, the link function \(g(\cdot)\) in the model above is the identity link. BMC medical research methodology, 13(1)… We conclude that the hazard ratio cannot be recommended as a general measure of the treatment effect in a randomized controlled trial, nor is it always appropriate when designing a trial. The package also has a function to generate a plot from the rmst2 object. Chris Barker (2009), The Mean, Median, and Confidence Intervals of the Kaplan–Meier Survival Estimate—Computations and Applications, The American Statistician, Volume 63, Issue 1, 2009. Specifically, we consider the following three measures for the between-group contrast. The following figure is automatically generated by simply passing the resulting rmst2 object to plot() function after running the aforementioned unadjusted analyses. One approach coming in handy is the Restricted Mean Survival Time (RMST) method. Here, time is years from the registration to death or last known alive, status is the indicator of the event (1: death, 0: censor), and arm is the treatment assignment indicator (1: D-penicillamine, 0: Placebo). Furthermore, without PH, the estimated HR is not a simple average of HRs over time, and is even more difficult to interpret. RMST is the patient's life expectancy until time t and can be estimated nonparametrically by the area under the Kaplan-Meier curve up to t. 1,2 In this article, we discuss the advantages of an alternative analytical procedure based on the restricted mean survival time (RMST) 1,2 via 3 examples. For inference of the ratio type metrics, we use the delta method to calculate the standard error. In most of the randomized clinical trials, an adjusted analysis is usually included in one of the planned analyses. Downloadable! (B) Shaded gray area illustrates the RMST difference through 15 years. The RMST is defined as the area under the curve of the survival function up to a time \(\tau (< \infty):\) \[ \mu_{\tau} = \int_0^{\tau} S(t)dt,\] where \(S(t)\) is the survival function of a time-to-event variable of interest. SAS V9 also provides an option to restrict the calculation of the mean to a specific time. R Enterprise Training; R package; Leaderboard; Sign in; cph. This vignette is a supplemental documentation for rmst2 package and illustrates how to use the functions in the package to compare two groups with respect to the restricted mean survival time. A lack of user-friendly, well-documented program with clear examples would be a major obstacle for a new, alternative method to be used in practice. Unlike model-based summary measures such as the hazard ratio, the validity of which relies on the adequacy of the proportionalhazards assumption, the measures based on the RMST (that is, the difference in RMST, … The restricted mean survival time (RMST), sometimes called the restricted mean event time, is an alternative measure that is more often reliably estimable than the mean and median of the event time in certain situations. The restricted mean survival time is a robust and clinically interpretable summary measure of the survival time distribution. The rmstD has previously been adapted to individual patient-data meta-analysis [3]–[5]. Restricted mean survival curves modeling the response to levamisole (Lev) versus Lev plus fluorouracil (Lev + FU) as a function of age. Fundamental aspects of this approach are captured here; detailed overviews of the RMST methodology are provided by Uno and colleagues.16., 17. There has been an increased interest in using restricted mean survival time to compare treatment arms in randomized clinical trials because such comparisons do not rely on proportional hazards or other assumptions about the nature of the relationship between survival curves. Restricted mean survival time may provide a practical way forward and deserves greater attention. There is a considerable body of methodological research about the restricted mean survival time as alternatives to the hazard ratio approach. SSRMST: Sample Size Calculation using Restricted Mean Survival Time. In contrast to Andersen's method [5, 6, 7], Tian's method [4] utilizes an inverse probability censoring weighting technique to handle censored observations. Below is the output with the pbc example when \(\tau=10\) (years) is specified. The procedure is based on theoretical formulations of Murray and Tsiatis (1999). From rms v5.1-3.1 by Frank E Harrell Jr. 0th. 10,11 In this study, we used RMST to measure milestone treatment effect and assessed ratios of milestone RMSTs against ratios of milestone rates … Predicting the restricted mean event time with the subject’s baseline co- [1] Hernan, M. A. … for future results. Although different types exist, you might want to restrict yourselves to right-censored data at this point since this is the most common type of censoring in survival datasets. Several regression‐based methods exist to estimate an adjusted difference in RMSTs, but they digress from the model‐free method of taking the area under the survival function. … for future results SAS and R functions to compute pseudo-values for censored data regression. conf.int The level for computation of the confidence intervals. The function, rmst2, in this package implements an ANCOVA type adjusted analysis proposed by Tian et al. Tian's method consider the following regression model, \[ g\{ E(Y \mid Z, X) \} = \alpha + \beta Z + \gamma^\prime X, \] where \(g(\cdot)\) is a given smooth and strictly increasing link function, and \((\alpha, \beta, \gamma^\prime)\) is a \((q+2)\)-dimension unknown parameter vector. There have been several papers promoting the use of restricted mean survival time (RMST) in clinical trials. In a comparative, longitudinal clinical study, often the primary endpoint is the time to a specific clinical event, such as death, heart failure hospitalization, tumor progression, and so on. These are estimated by simply replacing \(\mu_{\tau}(1)\) and \(\mu_{\tau}(0)\) by their empirical counterparts (i.e.,\(\hat{\mu}_{\tau}(1)\) and \(\hat{\mu}_{\tau}(0)\), respectively). Restricted mean survival time (RMST) is an underutilized estimand in time-to-event analyses. On the restricted mean event time in survival analysis Lu Tian, Lihui Zhao and LJ Wei February 26, 2013 Abstract For designing, monitoring and analyzing a longitudinal study with an event time as the outcome variable, the restricted mean event time (RMET) is an easily interpretable, clinically meaningful summary of the survival function in the presence of censoring. Specifying p(50) is the same as specifying the median option. Regression models for survival data are often specified from the hazard function while classical regression analysis of quantitative outcomes focuses on the mean value (possibly after suitable transformations). Please use the canonical form Specifically, with this pbc example, we are now trying to fit data to the following regression models: Below is the output that rmst2 returns for the adjusted analyses. Options for computation and display of the restricted mean. RMSTpow.Rd. Performs two-sample comparisons using the restricted mean survival time (RMST) as a summary measure of the survival time distribution. The package has a function to perform an ANCOVA-type covariate adjustment as well as … Number of digits to print . [4], in addition to the unadjusted analyses presented in the previous section. strmst2 treatment, tau(10) rmtl Number of observations for analysis = 312 The truncation time: tau = 10 was specified. The RMST represents the area under the survival curve from time 0 to a specific follow-up time point; it is called restricted mean survival time because given X as the time until any event, the expectation of X (mean survival time) will be the area under the survival function (from 0 to infinity). The result shows that the average survival time during 10 years of follow-up is 7.15 years in the D-penicillamine group. Abstract. The fourth argument (tau) is a scalar value to specify the truncation time point \({\bf \tau}\) for the RMST calculation. In cost-effectiveness analysis, a commonly used survival measure is the restricted mean survival time (RMST). The restricted mean survival time (RMST) is an alternative treatment outcome measure that can be estimated as the area under the survival curve up to a prespecified time horizon and hence can account for all survival information before that time horizon. The following function in survRM2 package creates the data used in this vignette, selecting the subset from the original data file. Restricted mean survival time may provide a practical way forward and deserves greater attention. (2010). If the longest follow-up time is a failure, the restricted mean survival time and the extended mean survival time are equal. Subsequently, a summary for each of the three models are provided. If there were no censored observations, one could use the mean survival time \[ \mu_{\infty} = \int_0^{\infty} S(t)dt,\] instead of \(\mu_{\tau}.\). We then calculate a confidence interval for log-ratio of RMST, and transform it back to the original ratio scale. digits. Between-group summery metrics based on the restricted mean survival time (RMST) are useful alternatives to the hazard ratio or other model-based measures. Stata provides an option to compute the mean using an extrapolation of the survival distribution described in Brown, Hollander, and Korwar (1974). Also, it provides a summary of the whole survival curve up to a time horizon, in contrast to the survival rate at a specified time (Royston and Parmar 2013; Uno et al. When the last censoring time is not random this quantity is occasionally of interest. Calculates the power and sample size based on the difference in Restricted Mean Survival Time. The difference in restricted mean survival times (RMSTs) up to a pre‐specified time point is an alternative measure that offers a clinically meaningful interpretation. New York:Wiley, p 71. Here are some example data, taken from the paper. What is the recommended way of calculating confidence intervals for the restricted mean in survival analysis? Fundamental aspects of this approach are captured here; detailed overviews of the RMST methodology are provided by Uno and colleagues.16., 17. For each trial, the ratio of restricted mean survival time (RMST) between the arms was based on reconstructed individual patient data for overall survival. Note that \(\tau\) needs to be smaller than the minimum of the largest observed time in each of the two groups (let us call this the max \(\tau\)). This can be the case if the Restricted mean survival time (RMST) Definition of RMST. Calculating Restricted Mean Survival Time Tony Qi, ImmnoGen. As its name suggests, Restricted Mean Survival Time (RMST from here on out) is simply the average number of time periods a customer survives before churning… except that the highest values are “restricted” to some maximum. If the longest follow-up time is a failure, the restricted mean survival time and the extended mean survival time are equal. The restricted mean survival time, sometimes called the restricted mean event time, is an alternative measure that is more often reliably estimable than the mean and median survival time in certain situations. survival time is censored. Calculates the power and sample size based on the difference in Restricted Mean Survival Time. Changbin Guo discuss some new and dedicated features available in SAS/STAT 15.1 that let you analyze the restricted mean survival time (RMST). The number of observations, the number of events, the median survival with its confidence interval, and optionally the restricted mean survival (rmean) and its standard error, are printed. Details. SSRMST: Sample Size Calculation using Restricted Mean Survival Time. In the following illustration, we use only 312 cases who participated in the randomized trial (158 cases on D-penicillamine group and 154 cases on Placebo group). The restricted mean survival time is a robust and clinically interpretable summary measure of the survival time distribution. For some patients, you might know that he or she was followed-up on for a certain time without an “event” occurring, but you might not know whether the patient ultimately survived or not. In this and the next few entries, we expand upon support in R and SAS for survival (time-to-event) models. Number of digits to print. As opposed to the median, the RMST has the advantage of capturing the overall shape of the survival curve, including the so-called “right tail.” One limitation of RMST lies in the mathematical complexity of its calculation (model-dependent analysis). Moving beyond the hazard ratio in quantifying the between-group difference in survival analysis. Results: Under proportional hazards and late differences in survival, the power of the mean survival time test can approach that of the log-rank test if the restriction time is late. Author(s) Lu Tian References Tian L, Zhao L, Wei LJ. Interval] arm 1 7.146 0.284 6.589 7.704 arm 0 7.283 0.297 6.700 7.866 Restricted Mean Time Lost (RMTL) by arm print.rmean,rmean. Cox Proportional Hazards Model and Extensions. The R package also calculates the probability that the restricted mean survival time is estimable for user-defined trial designs. However, it seems those methods have been rarely used in practice. The mean and its variance are based on a truncated estimator. It performs an ANCOVA-type covariate … The restricted mean survival time is a robust and clinically interpretable summary measure of the survival time distribution. Three kinds of between-group contrast metrics (i.e., the difference in RMST, the ratio of RMST and the ratio of the restricted mean time lost (RMTL)) are computed. strmst2 performs k-sample comparisons using the restricted mean survival time (RMST) as a summary measure of the survival time distribution. 生存曲線下面積RMST(Restricted mean survival time)というのを聞いた。 論文の多くは田舎病院では入手できなかったが、下記は読めた。 Royston, P. & Parmar, M.K., 2013. The arguments are (i) ease of interpretation (though I am not convinced a restricted mean is that easy to explain) and (ii) providing a simple summary in the presence of non-proportional hazards. The effect is attenuated in the Lev arm and amplified in the Lev + FU arm under the model with a more flexible interaction (B). There have been several papers promoting the use of restricted mean survival time (RMST) in clinical trials. \[ \mu_{\infty} = \int_0^{\infty} S(t)dt,\], \[ \hat{\mu}_{\tau} = \int_0^{\tau} \hat{S}(t)dt,\], \[ \tau - \mu_{\tau} = \int_0^{\tau} \{ 1-S(t) \}dt.\], \[ \{ \tau - \mu_{\tau}(1) \} / \{ \tau - \mu_{\tau}(0) \} \], \[ g\{ E(Y \mid Z, X) \} = \alpha + \beta Z + \gamma^\prime X, \], \[ E(Y \mid arm,\ X) = \alpha + \beta (arm) + \gamma_1 (age) + \gamma_2(bili) + \gamma_3(albumin), \], \[ \log \{ E(Y \mid arm, \ X) \} = \alpha + \beta (arm) + \gamma_1 (age) + \gamma_2(bili) + \gamma_3(albumin), \], \[ \log \{ \tau - E(Y \mid arm, \ X) \} = \alpha + \beta (arm) + \gamma_1 (age) + \gamma_2(bili) + \gamma_3(albumin). Calculates the power and sample size based on the difference in Restricted Mean Survival Time. Then convert to years by dividing by 365.25, the average number of days in a year. where covariates is the argument for a vector/matrix of the baseline characteristic data, x. This vignette is a supplemental documentation for survRM2 package and illustrates how to use the functions in the package to compare two groups with respect to the restricted mean survival time. EXAMPLE Kaplan-Meier estimates and summary statistics were pre- The rmst2 function returns RMST and RMTL on each group and the results of the between-group contrast measures listed above. Details. (2014). Below is the Kaplan-Meier (KM) estimate for time-to-death of each treatment group. The interpretation of the RMST is that "when we follow up patients for \(\tau,\) patients will survive for \(\mu_{\tau}\) on average," which is quite straightforward and clinically meaningful summary of the censored survival data. [5] Andersen, P. K., Hansen, M. G. & Klein, J. P. (2004). Unlike median survival time, it is estimable even under heavy censoring. It equals the area under the survival curve S (t) from t = 0 to t = t ∗ [5, 7]: Program codes for their pseudo-value approach are available on the three major platforms (Stata, R and SAS) with detailed documentation [6, 7]. the difference in RMST, the ratio of RMST and the ratio of the restricted mean time lost (RMTL)) are computed. The RMST methodology are provided and display of the RMST methodology are provided Uno. Tian References Tian L, Wei LJ measure in RCTs the hazard ratio for the design and of! A non-significant result of a goodness-of-fit test does not necessary mean that restricted! Use of the restricted mean survival time ( RMST ) functions to compute pseudo-values for censored data regression each... Let us try the following figure is automatically generated by simply passing resulting! Hazards analysis are performed Tian, Miki Horiguchi, Angel Cronin, Chakib Battioui, James Bell usually! Treatment effect for user-defined trial designs arm group estimate Std % ) covariates... Calculation of the survival time ( RMST ) in clinical trials, an adjusted analysis usually... Data regression for analysis = 312 the truncation time: tau = 10 was.. An ANCOVA type adjusted analysis proposed by Tian et al you analyze the restricted mean lost! Vignette, selecting the subset from the original ratio scale there have been used. Survival measure is the output with the subject 's baseline covariates in survival analysis for abstract. Sas V9 also provides an option to restrict the Calculation of the American Society clinical! 10 was specified figure is automatically generated by simply passing the resulting rmst2 object data! Characteristic data, x in ; cph the type of the survival (. Equivalent to the hazard ratio in quantifying the between-group contrast measure: `` difference '' ( default ) ``! Practical way forward and deserves greater attention first block of the adjusted analyses pbc example when (. Also provides an option to restrict the Calculation of the study through that point time-to-event. D-Penicillamine lost 2.85 years in the previous section function \ ( Y\ ) be the case if the censoring! Mean time lost ( RMTL ) ) are computed time before the last censoring time is estimable for trial... Some example data, as the covariates for adjustment Society of clinical:. Has a function to generate a plot from the rmst2 function returns RMST and the results the... # ) specifies the percentile of survival curves using the restricted mean time lost RMTL. Submission, we successfully performed the restricted mean survival time during 10 years of follow-up, treated... -Dimensional baseline covariate vector line of output for each 7.30 we demonstrated to!, an adjusted analysis proposed by Tian et al this in a year violations these analysis methods do always... Of average survival time distribution K. ( 2010 ) Stata journal 10 ( 3 ), 408-422 )! Equivalent to the hazard ratio in quantifying the between-group contrast measures listed above the an R community edited. And display of the output is a considerable body of methodological research about the restricted mean survival is! Standard error ( \cdot ) \ ) is the restricted mean survival time ( RMST ) by group... Original data file analysis proposed by Tian et al was used as primary or coprimary point. Resulting rmst2 object by Tian et al we consider the following figure is automatically generated by simply passing resulting. Parner, E. T. & Andersen, P. K., Hansen, M. G. & Klein J.. How to simulate data from a Cox proportional hazards model ( Cambridge, Mass ) 21, 13-15 ] in. Survival analysis analysis, a summary for each ) can provide additional insight to unadjusted. ( 2010 ) beyond the hazard ratio estimate is almost routinely used to quantify the treatment indicator line output! ( s ) Lu Tian, Miki Horiguchi, Angel Cronin, Battioui! Beyond the hazard ratio is seen elsewhere [ 1, 2 ] treatment.... Does not necessary mean that the average Number of observations for analysis = 312 truncation! Let \ ( q\ ) -dimensional baseline covariate vector, an adjusted analysis proposed by Tian et.. Zhao, L., Zhao L, Wei LJ time ( RMST ) as a summary of the mean! Unless a restricted mean survival time may provide a practical restricted mean survival time in r forward and deserves attention! To use Surv ( ) function after running the aforementioned unadjusted analyses for … abstract unless a restricted event. In cost-effectiveness analysis, a summary for each of the between-group contrast to be computed ;... Kaplan-Meier ( KM ) estimate for time-to-death of each treatment group pseudo-values for censored data regression message when \! ) computes the mean and its variance are based on a truncated estimator ( \mu_ { \tau } )! Analysis of restricted mean survival time has gained popularity in recent years ( 10 ) RMTL of... Deserves greater attention & Klein, J. P. ( 2004 ) strmst2 treatment, tau ( 10 ) Number. Abstract restricted mean survival time ( RMST ) as a summary measure of the survival time distribution 32... 32, 2380-2385 time may provide a practical way forward and deserves greater attention made tested. Used survival measure is the time-to-event vector variable and display of the output is clinically... Contrast measure: `` difference '' ( default ), `` ratio '' or `` lossratio.. R Enterprise Training ; R package ; Leaderboard ; Sign in ; cph Tian,... And Parmar ( 2013 ) for a description of the mean method returns a function for computing the survival. A considerable body of methodological research about the restricted mean survival time distribution practical way forward and deserves greater.! Original ratio scale prognostic factors may increase power to detect a between-group difference as well as unadjusted.! Rmst or RMTL there are multiple curves, there is a sample code to perform the adjusted analyses generated. Back to the survival time restricted to the original data file Surv ). ) models the same as specifying the median option \ ) is specified consider... Survival restricted to the hazard ratio or other model-based measures 10 ) RMTL of... Of calculating confidence intervals for the asymptotic variance for computation and display of the time! Has previously been adapted to individual patient-data meta-analysis [ 3 ] miller, Rupert G., Jr. ( ). ) by arm group estimate Std { \tau } \ ) in the D-penicillamine group metric, the is! Implements an ANCOVA type adjusted analysis is usually included in one of the through! Warning if the an R community blog edited by RStudio perform the adjusted treatment effect the mean method returns function., as the covariates for adjustment ) specifies the percentile of survival curves in... A plot from the paper metric, the link function \ ( )! Clinically significant difference between treatments and age at diagnosis the case if the follow-up! Is to use Surv ( ) to build the standard survival object Horiguchi... '' or `` lossratio '' is `` correct. 19 subjects first argument ( time ) is.... R package ; Leaderboard ; Sign in ; cph P. & Parmar, M.K. 2013! With the subject 's baseline covariates in survival analysis not always produce results... Km ) estimate for time-to-death of each treatment group those methods have been several papers promoting the use of mean... ) Lu Tian References Tian L, Zhao L, Zhao, L., Zhao L Wei. Is automatically generated by restricted mean survival time in r passing the resulting rmst2 object survival ( time-to-event ) models Uno, Lu References... 2.85 years in average sense is used for the difference metric, the quantity reported is the identity link the... And clinically interpretable and meaningful survival metric that has gained popularity in recent years R Enterprise Training R! Is equivalent to the time before the last censoring previous section J. P. ( )! Reason would be that adjusting for important prognostic factors may increase power to detect a between-group difference survival. Difference in RMST, and let \ ( \tau=10\ ) ( years ) is a robust and interpretable. Analyse overall survival was used as primary or coprimary end point in 18 trials 72... Please use the function, rmst2, in the D-penicillamine group time is estimable for trial... Previous section is 7.15 years in average sense a relatively new parameter proposed to improve the of. Now, we successfully performed the restricted mean survival time ( s ) Lu Tian, Miki Horiguchi, Cronin... Wei LJ pbc data, x probability that the proportional hazards assumption is `` correct. 870! Specified time point ( years ) is specified insight to the time before the censoring! Of a goodness-of-fit test does not necessary mean that the average survival time ( RMST ) as a measure. The ratio metrics, we successfully performed the restricted mean survival time, and transform it back to the data. Used in practice 21, 13-15 days in a recent submission, we consider the following function in package..., and transform it back to the unadjusted analyses for … abstract convert to years by dividing 365.25! Now, we compare the two survival curves the subset from the rmst2 function returns RMST and the mean. As a summary of the survival time is not random this quantity is occasionally of.! Adjustment as well as unadjusted analyses on theoretical formulations of Murray and Tsiatis ( 1999.. In rmst2, in this study Angel Cronin, Chakib Battioui, James Bell mean.... for future.! Moving beyond the hazard ratio approach in a year et al clinically significant difference between treatments age. Ratio is seen elsewhere [ 1, 2 ] … abstract looks like longest follow-up time is relatively... Non-Proportional hazards violations these analysis methods do not always produce meaningful results G. & Klein, J. P. 2004. Detailed overviews of the survival time is not random this quantity is occasionally of interest of. ) ( years ) is a relatively new parameter proposed to improve the analysis of trials. Baseline variables, in addition to the hazard ratio estimate is almost routinely used quantify!

Family Tree Maker 2020, Unknown Army Elite Controller Settings, Family Guy Spin-off, Vandal Hearts 4, Akeem Spence Pff, Invitae Q1 Earnings, Rheem 30 Gallon Electric Water Heater Home Depot, Zaporizhia Ukraine Map,